Sherlock Before Sherlock · The Reception

Old Marvel in the
Holmes Collections

“I was fascinated by the resemblance to Holmes and that Old Marvel came before Holmes appeared on the scene. Well done!”— Timothy J. Johnson, Curator

The University of Minnesota’s Sherlock Holmes Collections — the world’s largest gathering of material related to Sherlock Holmes and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle — accepted the Old Marvel hardback into its archive.

Vintage detective book with top hat and magnifying glass.

A Place at 221B

A new addition to the Sherlock Holmes Collections.

The Sherlock Holmes Collections at the University of Minnesota Library constitute the world’s largest gathering of material related to Sherlock Holmes and his creator Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. An inquiry to curator Timothy J. Johnson brought a favourable response, so a limited-edition hardback copy of Old Marvel, The Scientific Detective was promptly dispatched.

Among Mr. Johnson’s kind remarks were these: “Mr. Holmes left a copy of your beautiful book in the sitting room at 221B Baker Street, which I managed to capture in a few photos. It is a delightful addition to our collections. I was fascinated by the resemblance to Holmes and that Old Marvel came before Holmes appeared on the scene. Well done!”

— Timothy J. Johnson, Curator, Special Collections & Rare Books, E. W. McDiarmid Curator of the Sherlock Holmes Collections, University of Minnesota Libraries.

From the Library

Old Marvel at 221B Baker Street.

Vintage detective book with top hat and magnifying glass.

Old Marvel resting on the violin case at 221B

Vintage comic book titled "Old Marvel" resting on an antique upholstered sofa.

In the Holmes chair, Andersen Library

Man holding "Old Marvel" comic book in a bookstore aisle.

Curator Timothy J. Johnson with the hardback

Vintage Marvel comic book titled "Old Marvel" held in hand on library shelf.

A new addition to the Sherlock Holmes Collections

From the Curator

I was fascinated by the resemblance to Holmes and that Old Marvel came before Holmes appeared on the scene. Well done!

— Timothy J. Johnson, Curator, Sherlock Holmes Collections

Old Marvel, the Scientific Detective

Available on Amazon.

Continue browsing the shop.

Sherlock Before Sherlock · The Discovery

A Rare 1884 Serial Story

Joe Rainone’s discovery of an 1884 American detective story featuring a Sherlock-like character — published three years before the first Holmes novel.

Flagship Series · 1878–1894

The Joe Phenix Detective Series

Eleven NYC-detective novels by Albert W. Aiken, originally serialized for newsstand readers in 1880s New York.

All Editions · Paperback & Kindle

Where to Buy

Park Road Books in Charlotte. Amazon worldwide. Kindle on every device. Audible coming soon.